The Best Rolled Sugar Cookies

Plays165,257

See how to make a classic five-star sugar cookie. This favorite Allrecipes recipe has 5,000 reviews, and an art gallery’s worth of photos of these bea... See moreutifully decorated sugar cookies have been posted—more than 1,200! Get Jill’s top-rated recipe for The Best Rolled Sugar Cookies. The best part about these sugar cookies? They’re foolproof! So easy to make. Get more ideas for Homemade Food Gifts >>

Share It

The Chatter

designerdoug

Dec 26, 2013 11:54 PM

Aloha! I concur with Mimi3 and several others... what a total waste of ingredients and time. My dough was far too sticky and I had let it sit in the fridge overnight. It stuck to the rolling pin and was so fragile that the tips of my cookies broke off before I got them to the cookie sheet. I tasted the finished product and it was so awful, I think cardboard would have better flavor. I baked two sheets of these and ended up dumping the entire contents in the trash. I am still shocked at how many people rate this recipe so high. DO NOT WASTE YOUR TIME ON THESE!

Mimi3

Dec 25, 2013 3:25 PM

THIS IS THE WORST recipe for sugar cookies I have EVER made!!! Do NOT make this because you use good ingredients but 5 cups of flour???? That's all you taste is the flour!!!!!!!!! YUCK!!!!!!!! They don't ever taste sweet no matter how much sugar you put on top of the cookie!!!!!!!!!!!

JOYCE JONES

Dec 16, 2013 7:02 PM

will try this recipe for christmas

You'll Also Like

Best Chocolate Chip Cookies Plays409,742

Best Chocolate Chip …

How to Make Sugar Cookies Plays316,380

How to Make Sugar Co…

Easy Sugar Cookies Plays237,315

Easy Sugar Cookies

Sugar Cookies Plays196,234

Sugar Cookies

Cracked Sugar Cookies I Plays17,631

Cracked Sugar Cookie…

Best Peanut Butter Cookies Ever Plays83,950

Best Peanut Butter C…

Soft Sugar Cookies IV Plays56,284

Soft Sugar Cookies I…

Absolutely the Best Chocolate Chip Cookies Plays81,054

Absolutely the Best …

    Top

    <

    previous video:

    Absolutely the Best Chocolate Chip Cookies

    Plays81,000

    >

    next video:

    Best Chocolate Chip Cookies

    Plays409,530